PNAS · 2025
Searching for signs of life in the JWST era
With Sara Seager, Lucas Ellerbroek, William Bains and Janusz Petkowski, I reviewed what JWST's first results mean for the search for gases produced by life. Only a handful of temperate planets, all orbiting small, cool stars, are within JWST's reach.
Getting from a transit to a claim about a planet takes four steps: the observations, the processing that turns pixels into a spectrum, the model fits that infer gas abundances, and the interpretation. For WASP-107 b, independent analyses agreed on its methane and on the chemistry that methane implies. For the sub-Neptune TOI-270 d, two teams found methane and water in the same JWST data. Small differences in the abundances then led one team to a water-rich planet with a hot ocean and the other to a thick atmosphere of hydrogen, water and methane over a rocky interior.
The claimed dimethyl sulfide on K2-18 b fails all three tests we set for any sign of life: a robust detection, attribution to the right gas, and an interpretation that excludes non-biological sources. JWST may be able to flag a planet as a candidate, but a reliable detection of life will need future telescopes.